Town Hall Citizen

People Have the Power

Ralph Nader: Stop Repeating the Vast Undercount of Gazan Deaths. It Is Far Greater.

"Enough already of the media’s lazy indifference to the vast undercount of the Palestinian death toll from Netanyahu’s genocidal daily bombing and shelling of Gaza’s defenseless civilian population."

Ralph Nader: Stop Repeating the Vast Undercount of Gazan Deaths. It Is Far Greater.

"I’m referring to all the media – the corporate media, the public media, and the independent media. They all stick with the Hamas Ministry of Health’s (MOH) count of named victims whose corpses have been identified by hospitals and mortuaries. For months there have been no operating hospitals and mortuaries to send their grisly data to the Health Ministry".

Ralph has been talking about the vast undercount of Palestinian deaths for some time now. As of now, the official death toll reported by the Hamas Ministry of Health is around 55,000.

As Ralph explains in this piece from February 025, Hamas has motivations to under report the death count.

Stop Repeating the Vast Undercount of Gazan Deaths. It Is Ten Times Greater. - Ralph Nader
By Ralph Nader February 21, 2025 Enough already of the media’s lazy indifference to the vast undercount of the Palestinian death toll from Netanyahu’s genocidal daily bombing and shelling of Gaza’s defenseless civilian population. I’m referring to all the media – the corporate media, the public media, and the independent…

Here's a clip from this week's Ralph Nader Radio Hour where Ralph talks more about the death count.

audio-thumbnail
Ralph on the Gazan deaths undercount
0:00
/65.74125

I believe the "population shrinkage" reference Ralph mentions comes from a report that recently surfaced on social media. However this piece from the AP discredits the 400,000 number.

FACT FOCUS: Posts misrepresent report to falsely claim nearly 400,000 Palestinians are missing
Harvard published no such study. This estimate misrepresents a map included in a report by a professor at Israel’s Ben Gurion University that shows the distance between new aid distribution compounds in Gaza and three main populations centers.

I don't know what the real death count in Gaza is. Probably no one does. But I believe it's far greater than what's being reported, for all the reasons Ralph mentions. And because there are no functioning hospitals in Gaza now.

WATCH NOW: ‘Gaza: Doctors Under Attack’ – The Full Film They Didn’t Want You To See
Exclusive: The powerful film the BBC refused to air is out now, released globally by Zeteo. It documents Israel’s destruction of Gaza’s hospitals and the killing of Palestinian doctors.

I've been following Ralph for years. It's not like him to use numbers he's not sure or confident of. I've posted a question about this on his substack, I'll post back any replies.

tty next time,